Polish-Ukrainian Studies

V. Zaikyn and М. Rudnyckyj: a Dialogue of Two Foreigners about Galycian Literature

2018, 5, No. 5

Sofiia Kohut

DOI

10.32612/uw.23535644.2018.pp.81-92

Publication date

12.04.2018

Publishing model

open access

License type

CC BY 4.0 Int.

Field

Dziedzina nauk humanistycznych

Discipline

literaturoznawstwo

Language of publication

Ukrainian, English, Polish

Downloads

PDF 672 KB

Article

Number of views:60

Number of downloads:39

Crossref citations:0

Altmetric score:0

Abstract

A review of V. Zaikyn is one of the most interesting and competent reviews on the book of М. Rudnyckyj “Between an idea and form” (Mizh idejeju i formoju) (1932) in Lviv in press of intermilitary period. This review is possible to consider as unique, as it is a maximally tolerant, attentive and self-weighted estimation of book by М. Rudnyckyj as a standard of liberal criticism, payed by a ideological opponent — supporter of traditional Orthodoxal Christian world view. Contrasting collision and contrasting two cardinally different world views, absolutely different systems of values and cultural coordinates that contain review and criticized book, are very interesting for a modern research and allow to understand the spiritual range of problems and cultural tradition of intermilitary literary process.

Keywords:

V. Zaikyn,М. Rudnyckyj,intermilitary literary process,Orthodoxal Christianity,liberal criticism

Bibliography

M. Rudnytskyi, Mizh ideieiu i formoiu, Lviv 1932.

V. Zaikyn, Probliemy ukrainskoi literaturnoi krytyky y estetyky v liberalnim osvitlenni, Dzvony, chys. 7–8; chys. 9; chys. 10, 1932; N. N. (I. Zubenko?), Z «probliem» ukrainskoi krytyky, Dazhboh, chys. 2, 1932; V. Resh-Lozovskyi, Z literaturnoi krytyky Huliai-Polia, Vistnyk, kn. 11, 1934; Essaye krytyka ukraińskiego, Wiadomości Literackie, 21 sierp. (No 36), 1932; mh (M. Hechter (?)) Zwischen Idee und Forme, Prager Presse, 29 Juli, 1932.

N. Kuchma, Literaturna krytyka v Zakhidnii Ukraini 20–30-kh rr. XX st., Ternopil 2004.

V. Zaikyn, Probliemy ukrainskoi literaturnoi krytyky y estetyky v liberalnim osvitlenni, Dzvony, chys. 7–8; chys. 9; chys. 10, 1932..

B.-I. Antonych, Mizh zmistom i formoiu (pidhot. publ. ta peredm. M. Ilnytskoho), „Nauka i kultura”, Kyiv 1990, vyp. 24.

D. Ilnytskyi, «Mizh ideieiu i formoiu» chy «Mizh zmistom i formoiu»: dialoh Mykhaila Rudnytskoho i Bohdana Ihoria Antonycha, Naukovyi visnyk Uzhhorodskoho universytetu, Seriia «Filolohiia. Sotsialni komunikatsii», vyp. 26, 2011.

Andrii Portnov, Viacheslav Zaikyn: emigratsiinyi istoryk iz bahatma oblychchiamy [v:] Andrii Portnov, Istorii istorykiv: Oblychchia y obrazy ukrainskoi istoriohrafii XX stolittia, Kyiv 2011.

Andrii Portnov, Istoriia, tserkva i konservatyvni tsinnosti v naukovii tvorchosti Viacheslava Zaikina, Instytut suspilnykh doslidzhen: Istoriia Ukrainy: Moderni chasy: elektronnyi resurs, http://www.uaterra.com.ua/ developments/history/modern/portnov_zaikin.htm.

M. Komarytsia, Vidobrazhennia literaturnoho protsesu v Halychyni 30-kh rr. na storinkakh katolytskoho zhurnalu «Dzvony» [v:] Teoretychni ta orhanizatsiini problemy formuvannia repertuaru ukrainskoi knyhy ta peri- odyky: dop. ta povidoml. Mizhnar. nauk. konf. 25-26 serp. 1995 r., Lviv 1996.

Andrii Portnov, Viacheslav Zaikyn: emigratsiinyi istoryk iz bahatma oblychchiamy [v:] Andrii Portnov, Istorii istorykiv: Oblychchia y obrazy ukrainskoi istoriohrafii XX stolittia, Kyiv 2011.

Kohut S., Viacheslav Zaikyn i Mykhailo Rudnytskyi: dialoh dvokh «chuzhyntsiv» pro halytsku literaturu [w:] "Studia Polsko-Ukraińskie", red. Walentyna Sobol, nr 5, wyd. Zakład Graficzny UW, Warszawa 2018, s. 81-92 .

Similar publications